“The point of Taking Children Seriously of course is not to have the children ‘rule’ the parents—but it is unavoidable that that is how it will be seen from the worldview of an authoritarian society. To an authoritarian worldview, the question is not ‘is there an authority in this situation’ but ‘who is the authority in this situation.’ In any situation where there is no authority, one will be invented or imagined.”
– Brett Williams
From the archives: Posted on 4th April 2001
Someone asked whether to outsiders (such as strangers and extended family members), Taking Children Seriously looks as though kids are ruling the house.
Outsiders see what they want to see.
“What do you say to statistics that claim that if you start letting toddlers rule the family, they’ll still be ruling when they’re teenagers?”
Well, duh. So what?
The point of Taking Children Seriously of course is not to have the children “rule” the parents—but it is unavoidable that that is how it will be seen from the worldview of an authoritarian society. To an authoritarian worldview, the question is not “is there an authority in this situation” but “who is the authority in this situation.” In any situation where there is no authority, one will be invented or imagined.
See also:
- Criticism of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child
- Why allow minors to disregard the guidance of their elders?
- Children who prefer to go to school
Brett Williams, 2001, ‘Do the kids rule?’, https://takingchildrenseriously.com/do-the-kids-rule/